New Home Building Brokers vs First Homebuilders: which fits a custom build?
What follows is judgment on fit, not just a scoreboard.
Side by side
- Google rating
- New Home Building Brokers: 4.9 (155 reviews)
- First Homebuilders: 4.6 (194 reviews)
- Services
- New Home Building Brokers: sustainable energy efficient, luxury home builders, building consultant, home builder
- First Homebuilders: sustainable energy efficient, display home volume builders, luxury home builders, building consultant
- Best for block type
- New Home Building Brokers: Narrow, sloping, or awkward lots needing custom design solutions
- First Homebuilders: Standard or near-standard blocks, land-and-build packages
- Best for buyer type
- New Home Building Brokers: Buyers who want an independent advocate managing builder and designer
- First Homebuilders: First-home buyers wanting one accountable, responsive team
- Temperament fit
- New Home Building Brokers: Hands-on clients who want to understand and negotiate contract terms
- First Homebuilders: Clients who want to be guided, with regular check-ins and less legwork
- Verification
- New Home Building Brokers: Google-verified
- First Homebuilders: Google-verified
- Composite score
- New Home Building Brokers: 91
- First Homebuilders: 87
What reviewers say
New Home Building Brokers
Clients consistently credit the brokers for converting stressful custom builds into controlled, enjoyable experiences. Anthony, Tristan, and Gavin work across design, builder selection, and contract negotiation, offering ongoing site support and transparent communication-particularly valued by first-time builders and those with complex lots.
The service spans custom homes, narrow and sloping blocks, house-behind-house designs, and duplex solutions. Staff maintain contact through handover and beyond; one reviewer noted support a decade after build completion. Multiple reviews highlight proactive problem-solving and the team's ability to align designers, builders, and clients toward a shared goal.
First Homebuilders
First Homebuilders stands apart for staff who pick up the phone within minutes and stay involved from land hunt through handover. Reviewers repeatedly name Rhys Palmer, Dan Costello, Dan Milne, Tiff, Elliot, Jamal, and Kien as guides who explain every step, answer silly questions at night, and treat clients like family rather than transactions.
Build sites are cleaned between trades, slabs go down weeks after settlement, and frames follow fast. Costs are locked in upfront. First-time buyers consistently describe feeling less overwhelmed because someone checked in on them, made site visits fit their work schedule, and stayed accessible even after handing them to the construction team. One reviewer who'd built before elsewhere said this experience was completely different, in the best way.
Which should you pick?
Pick New Home Building Brokers if
- Your block is narrow, sloping, or otherwise non-standard, requiring bespoke design and builder coordination
- You want an independent party negotiating contracts and managing costs across multiple builders or designers
- You're building a duplex or house-behind-house and need someone aligning all parties toward one outcome
Pick First Homebuilders if
- You want a single builder managing the whole process from land hunt through handover with named staff contacts
- Fast, predictable timelines matter (slabs within weeks of settlement) and your block doesn't need bespoke design work
- You're a first-home buyer who wants upfront, locked-in pricing and frequent hand-holding through an unfamiliar process
Verdict
The deciding factor is what "custom" means for your block. If you're dealing with a difficult site, a duplex, or any project where the designer and builder need active, independent coordination, New Home Building Brokers is set up for exactly that, with contract negotiation and complex-build experience reviewers cite going back years. If your custom home is more about getting a well-run, transparent build without a tricky site to solve, First Homebuilders' named staff and fast, cost-certain process make the experience less stressful. Choose based on how much your block itself demands a specialist, not just on the higher composite score.
Still working out which builder suits you?
Tell us what you need and compare quotes from suitable Home builders in Perth metro.
Enquiries from contact forms may be shared with partner providers, and we may earn a referral fee from those referrals. Our rankings and scores reflect only our published methodology and are never influenced by referral fees.
Questions people ask
- Which is better rated?
- New Home Building Brokers has a higher rating (4.9 vs 4.6) though First Homebuilders has more reviews (194 vs 155). Both show strong positive sentiment.
- Which is better for a sloping or narrow block?
- New Home Building Brokers, given its stated specialisation in non-standard blocks, house-behind-house designs, and duplex solutions.
- Which moves faster?
- First Homebuilders is noted for quick timelines, with slabs going down within weeks of settlement, which suits straightforward builds more than complex ones.
- Can either help with contract negotiation?
- New Home Building Brokers explicitly specialises in contract negotiation and cost management across builders and designers; First Homebuilders instead offers upfront, locked-in pricing as the builder itself.